Evidence searches for coursework or study.

Do not spend more than half an hour responding to a request that will be going solely towards coursework if you are not going to do a training session with the requester.

Important: Important

You should not perform a database search that is going solely towards coursework or study (like a dissertation) if the evidence search is part of the requester’s learning objectives or will be assessed as their work.

Planning

Respond to the requester promptly if you are not going to perform the search on their behalf, so that they are not waiting and relying on you to do their coursework for them while their deadline approaches.

If the requester is looking for a handful of recent peer reviewed papers on a topic for an assignment, direct them to the NHS Knowledge and Library Hub or your local discovery tool if you have one, with instructions, or offer to go through this with them (coaching them, discretely training them).

If the requester cannot/will not go through the process in person, and cannot/will not be signposted, and if time allows, consider sending them the results of a very quick cursory search and offer them further training.

Ask questions to ascertain if this is the case. Explain your policy to the requester, as not every student is aware that they cannot ask you to do uncredited coursework searches.

If their search is going solely towards coursework you can refer them to their university library services, or if time allows, offer training to the requester, suggesting that in a training session you can coach them through their search while they learn the principles of searching, and will come away with useful results.

If the requester stresses that the search results will also be used in their day-to-day clinical work to improve service and so it is permissible for you to do this search for them.

Offer them a training session where you can coach them through their search as they learn the principles of searching, so they can continue on their own if needed.

Instruct the requester to declare that they have had assistance if you do this – using your help without acknowledgement is plagiarism.

An exception to this rule are searches that are contributing towards a PhD as well as day-to-day clinical work. If you are asked to help be sure to emphasise that supervisors should be aware of your involvement, and included in correspondence where possible to ensure transparency and the rigour of the search. You should allow more time for such searches.

Execution

Go through a training session with the requester, getting them hands-on with the relevant database(s) and coaching them through the process, ensuring they come away with enough results to use for their coursework/study, plus the confidence and skills to find more on their own.

If the requester has asked for a handful of recent articles for an assignment and you are not going to train them, do not spend very long on this. You should signpost them to the appropriate resources (the KLHub) with instructions on how to use them.

If time allows and you perform a very quick cursory search of one of these sources for them, send the results to the requester along with your offer of training.

Depending on their topic (and which of the resources below your service is currently promoting or which you happen to have open when you receive the request) do one of the following.

Search the NHS Knowledge Hub

Quickly search the KLHub (or your local library discovery tool) with the date range set to the last few years and the “full text” filter turned on, and send a link to that results page to the requester.

Search a secondary source

Quickly search a secondary source, like the Trip Database, if appropriate to the subject and send a link to the results page for the requester, or copy/paste a few select recent relevant results into an email.

Search a clinical decision support tool

Quickly search a Clinical Decision Support tool (British Medical Journal (BMJ) Best Practice/DynaMed/UpToDate/Visual Dx) if accessible and appropriate to the subject, and copy links to suitable entries/topics for the requester.

Search the library catalogue

Quickly search the library catalogue for books and ebooks on the subject and copy links for the requester.

Do a scoping search

Perform a scoping search for the requester, searching by title within an appropriate bibliographic database (such as Pubmed) and copying a link to results page or quickly exporting results.

Results

If you train the requester, offer to look over their search strategy if they work on it after your session together - to provide some support and ideas to improve it (without doing it all for them).

If, rather than train or signpost the user, you do a very quick search for them, supply them with freely available full text access results, if possible. Explain that these are not comprehensive, but that they can discover more at a training session.

Examples

Example 1

Dear …

Hope this email finds you well.

Thank you for completing our online evidence search request form.

I regret that because your request for articles on “reflection and patient interviews” is going towards coursework/study, we cannot conduct a full search of the evidence on your behalf, as per our policy.

I have however done a quick search of the NHS Knowledge and Library Hub for peer-reviewed research articles from the last 5 years with the term "patient interview" in their titles, which you will be able to access the full text of, and/or download immediately. There's a link to them all here:

You can log in with you NHS OpenAthens username and password (see the yellow bar at the top of the page) to see the links to the full text. If you don't have a username/password you can sign-up for one. 

There are about 130 articles there to browse through altogether, covering lots of facets of patient interviews.

We can also offer you a training session where you can learn how to search healthcare databases on your specific topic and others should you wish, just let us know when suits and we can do this virtually or in person within a couple of hours.

Hope this helps, let me know if you have trouble accessing these results or you can't find anything useful amongst them.

All the best …

Example 2

Dear …

Hope this email finds you well.

Thank you for requesting an evidence search. I regret that as your search is going towards your coursework we cannot perform a full search on your behalf, as the literature search forms part of your learning objectives and will be assessed as your work.

We can instead arrange a training session at a time and place of your convenience where we can show you how to search the literature to find evidence on your topic. You'll come away with useful papers for your coursework and you’ll have done the majority of the literature search part! Please let me know when you'd like to arrange this training.

In the meantime here are some preliminary results I found by searching

We can find more results at the training session.

Look forward to hearing from you…

Page last reviewed: 4 August 2023
Next review due: 4 August 2024